Why The Ballon d’Or Rumors Matter

Nothing better epitomizes the current state of end-of-season football awards than the trophy presented blatter picto UEFA’s Best Player in Europe. I can’t decide whether it looks more like the remains of a long-dead scoliosis victim, or a three-dimensional rendition of Rembrandt’s “Carcass of Beef.”

In a sane world, the UEFA Best Player in Europe award wouldn’t even exist. In the past, football’s two most prestigious individual awards – the Ballon d’Or, created by France Football magazine; and the official FIFA World Player of the Year title – occasionally went to different players, which most people preferred to a boring consensus. But FIFA viewed those periodic discrepancies as a disruption in the Force, and in 2010, FIFA president Sepp Blatter merged the two awards to form a new, 100 percent definitive title: the FIFA Ballon d’Or. Just a year later, however, as part of an “initiative…aimed at reviving the spirit” of the old Ballon d’Or, UEFA launched its own award, undermining the merger’s objective.

Over the past three awards cycles, FIFA has not only failed to definitively settle the best player question, it may also have crossed the well-trodden line between administrative incompetence and outright corruption. Players like Tomas Rosicky and Thiago Silva have claimed that their Ballon d’Or votes were somehow changed at the last minute, and Jose Mourinho has announced that he will no longer attend FIFA awards ceremonies because “one, two, or three people called me saying they had voted for me [in the best manager category] but the vote showed up cast for somebody else.” Mourinho suspects a conspiracy.

And then last month, FIFA extended the voting period for this year’s Ballon d’Or, supposedly because many players had missed the original deadline. According to some tabloids, however, FIFA changed the deadline not to ensure that every eligible player votes but to help Cristiano Ronaldo, whose recent performances in World Cup qualifying have given new momentum to his Ballon d’Or campaign (yes, there is such a thing).

I don’t think FIFA has rigged the Ballon d’Or: after all, no one at FIFA would profit if Ronaldo wins. It seems clear, however, that the awards process, with its changing deadlines and administrative mishaps, is as disorganized as, well, virtually every other FIFA program. And since FIFA’s incompetence is the inevitable result of a corrupt system that places incompetent people in important jobs, we shouldn’t dismiss the latest set of rumors. Mourinho’s complaints may be self-serving, but they also point up the justifiable suspicion that has hung over FIFA since the World Cup voting scandal. I don’t think FIFA has rigged the Ballon d’Or, but I wouldn’t be particularly surprised to hear that it had.

But enough about FIFA. Zlatan Ibrahimovich has decided that end-of-season awards are a waste of time. “It matters more to some players,” Ibrahimovich said in an interview last month, but “I don’t need the Ballon d’Or to know I’m the best.”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: